The magic behind unicorn startups

Unicorns aren’t real, and neither are the valuations ascribed to many of the startups that say they’re worth US$1bil or more.


BEAM Team

3 Aug, 2017

The magic behind unicorn startups | BEAMSTART News

- From our Sponsors -

Unicorns aren’t real, and neither are the valuations ascribed to many of the startups that say they’re worth US$1bil or more.

About half of private companies with valuations exceeding US$1bil, known as unicorns, wouldn’t have earned the mythical title without the use of complex stock mechanics, according to a study by business professors at the University of British Columbia and Stanford University. The tools used to negotiate a higher share price with investors often come at the expense of employees and early shareholders, sometimes drastically reducing the actual value of their stock.

The chasm between public and private valuations is a topic of increasing prominence following several disappointing listings. Among them is Blue Apron Holdings Inc, which is trading well below the price venture capitalists paid in the last fundraising round.

Related: You can now raise funds for your business on BEAM

An often-overlooked explanation for the divide is buried in investor contracts. Blue Apron, which delivers meal kits to customers, gave stock preferences to Fidelity Investments and other backers in 2015 in exchange for a US$2bil valuation. The shares included a provision to receive additional equity if an initial public offering is set below a target price. Investors took advantage of the mechanism after Blue Apron’s mediocre IPO.

The use of special investor protections has soared in recent years as startups chase dreams of becoming a unicorn. A lofty valuation can build credibility and help recruit talent in a tight labour market. But it has also complicated the already-opaque process of valuing a private business.

One provision frequently afforded to investors is called a liquidation preference. It guarantees a minimum payout in the event of an acquisition or other exit. The study found that it can exaggerate a company’s valuation by as much as 94%. Researchers pointed to AppNexus, a digital advertising startup. The company sold shares with a liquidation preference that guaranteed new backers at least double the amount they put in if AppNexus is acquired.

Another common tool is known as a ratchet. This is what came back to bite Blue Apron after its IPO. Payments provider Square Inc faced a similar issue when it went public. Oscar Insurance Corp and Pivotal Software Inc have also doled out ratchets to shareholders. Ratchets can inflate a startup’s value by 56% or more, the study said.

Related: You can now find jobs on BEAM

The study looked at 116 unicorns founded after 1994, with average valuations of US$2.7bil. Researchers found that 11% of companies, including HomeAway and SolarCity, used preferential stock to boost their valuations to more than twice what they would be worth using the study’s fair value estimates. “Our results suggest that more attention should be paid to the contractual terms between investors and companies,” the report said.

But not every startup is grossly overvalued. For example, researchers found Uber Technologies Inc has only one instance of a liquidation preference. The study said Uber’s valuation of US$69bil is only 12% higher than the fair value approximation. Even at the lower estimate, Uber would still be the world’s most valuable tech startup.

Eschewing these financial instruments doesn’t guarantee favourable performance on public markets, though. Snap Inc was careful to minimise the use of special protections for its venture capital backers. Since going public in March, the social media company’s shares have dropped 23% below the IPO price.

Related:

- From our Sponsors -

Latest Jobs

English Technical/Legal Writer

Pacston Technology Group

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Full Time

USD 20000 — USD 60000 monthly

[URGENTLY NEEDED] Portuguese to English Proofreader

Elite Asia

Malaysia

Contract / Freelance

Salary Undisclosed

Junior Accounts Cum Admin Assistant

LABEL-LINE CORPORATION PTE LTD

Kallang, Singapore

Full Time

SGD 1600 — SGD 1800 monthly

HR Manager

Gamer's Hideout Sdn. Bhd.

Dataran Prima, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia

Full Time

MYR 3200 — MYR 3800 monthly

Head of Developers

TWGT

Manila, Philippines

Full Time

USD 2000 monthly

Financial Officer

PIVOT Fintech Pte Ltd

60, #11-25 Paya Lebar Rd, Paya, Singapore

Full Time

USD 5000 — USD 8000 monthly

Remote Sales Staff

Gann Markets

Remote Sales Staff , China (中国)

Full Time

USD 280 — USD 1000 monthly

Full Stack Software Engieer

HealthBeats Pte Ltd

Singapore

Full Time

SGD 4500 — SGD 6000 monthly

BEAMSTART is a hub for everything Startups, Entrepreneurship, and Innovation. Connect with a global community of people, and stay updated with the latest startup jobs, news, and discussions.

 
© 2016 - 2022 BEAMSTART. All Rights Reserved (Legal).